Amy Adams

Ashley

Embeth Davidtz

Madeleine

Ben McKenzie

Johnny

Alessandro Nivola

George

Celia Weston

Peg

Scott Wilson

Eugene

Alicia Van Couvering

Bernadette

Jerry Minor

Scout who stays outside

Matt Besser

Scout who goes in

Will Oldham

Bill Mooney, scout

Frank Hoyt Taylor

David Wark

Bobby Tisdale

Norman at Replacements, Ltd.

R. Keith Harris

Bud, young pastor

Jill Wagner

Millicent, friend at shower