Edith Meeks

Felicia Beacon ("Hero")

Rob LaBelle

Jay Wete ("Hero")

Evan Dunsky

Dr. MacArthur ("Hero")

Richard Anthony

Edward Comacho ("Hero")

Susan Norman

Nancy Olsen ("Horror")

Joe Dietl

Man in the Alley ("Horror")

James Cagnard

Bartender ("Horror")

Frankie Waters

Townsperson ("Horror")

Gary Ray

Additional Voices / Canon ("Horror" / "Homo")

James Lyons

Jack Bolton ("Homo")

John Leguizamo

Chancho ("Homo")

Ray Dragon

Fontenal Inmate ("Homo")

Michael A. Miranda

Fontenal Inmate ("Homo")

Anthony J. Ribustello

Fontenal Inmate ("Homo")

John Gleeson Connolly

Baton Inmate ("Homo")

Tom Cross

Baton Inmate ("Homo")

Tom Wayland

Background Voices ("Homo")

Kelly Reichardt

Townsperson ("Horror") (uncredited)