Carla Gugino

Cathy Rush

Marley Shelton

Sister Sunday

Ellen Burstyn

Mother St. John

David Boreanaz

Ed Rush

Margaret Anne Florence

Rosemary Keenan

Kate Nowlin

Colleen McCann

Malachy McCourt

Monsignor

Phyllis Somerville

Sister Sister

Jodie Lynne McClintock

Sister Thomas

Lauren Bittner

Mary Margaret O'Malley

Lauren Karl

Kelly MacDougal

John Peakes

Harry McHale

Ward Horton

Frankie Sharkey

Brooke Josephson

Mrs. Kincade

Jesse Draper

Mrs. Ballard

Tony Luke Jr.

Salvatore Galentino

Brandon Hannan

Tony Galentino

Christopher Mann

Julius Moore

Josh Green

Cowboy in bar

Pete Postiglione

Security Guard

Michael Smerconish

Reporter #1

Anthony Gargano

Reporter #2

Patrick McDade

Cupcake Buyer

Evan Bochetto

Locker Room Assistant

Gina Allegro

Rosemont Coach (uncredited)

Robert Bizik

Basketball Fan (uncredited)

David E. Brown

Basketball Referee (uncredited)

Rich Bryant

Immaculata Student (uncredited)

Jennifer Butler

Nun (uncredited)

Evangeline

College Student (uncredited)

Basil Kershner

Basketball Fan (uncredited)

Fallon Maressa

Student (uncredited)

Keith Moyer

Biker (uncredited)

Chelsea O'Toole

Nun (uncredited)

Charles Pendelton

Cab Driver / Featured (uncredited)

Vincent Riviezzo

Bank Customer (uncredited)

Mark Schroeder

Scorekeeper #2 (uncredited)

Ryan Tygh

Sporting Goods Stock Boy (uncredited)

Sonny Vellozzi

Scorekeeper (uncredited)

Ryan Windish

Monsignor Assistant (uncredited)