Warner Baxter

Joaquin Murrieta

Ann Loring

Señorita Juanita de la Cuesta

Bruce Cabot

Bill Warren

Margo

Rosa F. 'Rosita' de Murrieta

J. Carrol Naish

Three Fingered Jack

Soledad Jiménez

Madre Murrieta

Eric Linden

Johnnie 'Jack' Warren

Edgar Kennedy

Sheriff Judd

Charles Trowbridge

Ramon de la Cuesta

Harvey Stephens

Capt. Osborne

George Regas

Tomás

Francis McDonald

Pedro

Kay Hughes

Louise

Harry Woods

Pete

Sam Ash

Arriga

Hank Bell

Posse Man

Dick Botiller

Pancho

Frank Campeau

Coach Driver Steve

G. Pat Collins

Doc

Mathilde Comont

Señora Matinez

Pedro de Cordoba

Hacendado Wanting to Cooperate

Richard Cramer

Bartender

Nigel De Brulier

Padre at Wedding (uncredited)

Nick De Ruiz

Peón

Al Ferguson

Miner

Harold Goodwin

Slocum

Frank Hagney

Deputy Phil

Lew Harvey

Bill Young

Herbert Heywood

Hacendado Wanting to Fight

Si Jenks

Miner

Marc Lawrence

Manuel

George MacQuarrie

Smithers

J.P. McGowan

Danglong

Ivan Miller

Marshal

Carlotta Monti

Dancer

Tom Moore

Sheriff Hannan

Inez Palange

Nurse with Madre

Lee Phelps

Off-Key Singer Hank

Pedro Regas

Lookout Yelling 'Murrietta Comes!'

Jason Robards Sr.

Pancho

Lee Shumway

Deputy

Charles Stevens

Wedding Guest / Bandit

Ben Taggart

Rancher

Morgan Wallace

Hacendado Wanting to Fight

Gayne Whitman

Frank Yaconelli

Peón

Bob Burns

Miner