Peyton List

Aileen Wuornos

Tobin Bell

Lewis Fell

Lydia Hearst

Jennifer Fell

Nick Vallelonga

Victor Miller

Swen Temmel

Grady Miller

Andrew Biernat

Mitch Miller

Ashley Atwood

Older Aileen

Meadow Williams

Diane Pittman

Ben Smith-Petersen

Hobie

Leslie Stratton

Courtney

Christopher Corbin

Dewey

William "Will" Daubert

Jail Guard