Noël Wells

Zoe

Josh Radnor

Paul

Aya Cash

Jane

Carly Chaikin

Claire

Fortune Feimster

Sarah-Beth

Samira Wiley

Lana

Tristan Riggs

Little Boy (uncredited)

Rico LeBron

Fernando

Adam Shapiro

Justin (uncredited)

Wiley Wiggins

Zoe's Landlord