Matthew Rhys

Lloyd Vogel

Tom Hanks

Fred Rogers

Chris Cooper

Jerry Vogel

Susan Kelechi Watson

Andrea Vogel

Maryann Plunkett

Joanne Rogers

Enrico Colantoni

Bill Isler

Wendy Makkena

Dorothy Vogel

Tammy Blanchard

Lorraine Vogel

Noah Harpster

Todd

Carmen Cusack

Margy Whitmer

Kelley Davis

First AD

Christine Lahti

Ellen

Maddie Corman

Betty Aberlin

Daniel Krell

Mr. McFeely

Gretchen Koerner

Doctor

Gavin Borders

Young Boy

Jessica Hecht

Lila Vogel

Di Zhu

Waitress

Haley Jenkins

Puppeteer

Marc Petrosino

Puppeteer

Krizia Bajos

Argentinian Girl (uncredited)

Tom Bonello

WQED Grip and Electric (uncredited)

Francesca Calo

Train Passenger (uncredited)

Joe Fishel

Journalist (uncredited)

Kevin L. Johnson

Darin Scharf (uncredited)

Michael Masini

Richie (uncredited)

Patrick McDade

Rick (uncredited)

David Newell

Restaurant Patron (uncredited)

Khary Payton

Arthur Mendez - Telegraph Clerk (uncredited)

Alex Pérez

Parent (uncredited)

Jivan Xander Ramesh

Mr. Rogers' Fan (uncredited)

Scott Rapp

Bartender (uncredited)

Fred Rogers

Self (archive footage) (uncredited)

Joanne Rogers

Restaurant Patron (uncredited)

Rebecca Watson

Diana (uncredited)