Rob Lowe

Jesse James

Bill Paxton

Frank James

Randy Travis

Cole Younger

William Atherton

Allan Pinkerton

Todd Field

Bob Younger

Cole S. McKay

Sheriff Baylor

Dana Wheeler-Nicholson

Annie

Maria Pitillo

Zee

Luke Askew

Lone Rider

Sean Patrick Flanery

Zack Murphy

Alexis Arquette

Charlie Ford

John Pyper-Ferguson

Clell Miller

Nicholas Sadler

Arch Clements (as Nick Sadler)

David Arquette

(uncredited)