Penn Jillette

Self

Teller

Self

Caitlin Clarke

Carlotta / Celia McGuire

David Patrick Kelly

Fan

Leonardo Cimino

Ernesto

Ted Neustadt

Bob, the Host

Billy Morrissette

Frat Boy #2

Jon Cryer

Frat Boy #3

Christopher Durang

Jesus Freak

Camille Saviola

Airport Security Guard

Peggy Cosgrave

Ticket Agent

Madison Arnold

Slot Player

Jamie Tirelli

Maitre d'

Paul Calderon

Juan

Eddie Gorodetsky

Big Guy

Ben Lin

Rope Holder #1

James Randi

Rope Holder #3

Rob Elk

Heckler

Nancy Giles

TV Interviewer

Marilyn Cooper

Woman in Parking Lot

Robert LaSardo

Mugger #1

Tom Sizemore

Mugger #2

Reg E. Cathey

Fan’s Friend

Alan North

Old Cop