Drew Barrymore

Lisa Piper

Richard Mulligan

Barnie / Barnaby Barnicle

Eileen Brennan

Mrs. Piper / Widow Hubbard

Keanu Reeves

Jack Fenton / Jack-be-Nimble

Pat Morita

The Toymaster

Jill Schoelen

Mary Piper / Mary Contrary

Googy Gress

George / Georgie Porgie

Walter Buschhoff

Justice Grimm