Jeremy Sisto

Father John Buertein

Kristin Chenoweth

Linda Salerno

Brian Baumgartner

Fr. Ralph O'Brien

Bruce A. Young

Lloyd Montag

Tony Papenfuss

Zeke

Greta Oglesby

Miriam

Isabell O'Connor

Tessie Thomas

Patrick Coyle

Steven Miller

Linda Kelsey

Corrine Buerlein

Lola Lesheim

Della

Gene Larche

Gus

Emily Fradenburgh

Sharon

Dawn Brodey

Exotic Dancer

Jackson Bond

Danny Boyle

John Skelley

Henry

Joel Thingvall

Bartender (uncredited)