Sarah Jones

Belinda Simpson

Haylie Duff

Annie

Jordan Bridges

Lee Owens

Patty Duke

Mary

Courtney Halverson

Lillian

Michael Trevino

Joshua

Jeffrey Muller

Peter

Dahlia Salem

Mabel McQueen

Thomas Kopache

Reverend Davis

Daniel Beer

Lloyd McQueen

Jeff Clarke

Mr. Travis

Matthew Florida

Young Cowboy

Time Winters

Gus

Carson Bolde

Travis

Sauvion Morkunas

Cowboy (uncredited)