Natasha Lyonne

Megan

Clea DuVall

Graham

Cathy Moriarty

Mary Brown

RuPaul

Mike

Melanie Lynskey

Hilary

Katharine Towne

Sinead

Katrina Phillips

Jan

Joel Michaely

Joel

Douglas Spain

Andre

Kip Pardue

Clayton

Eddie Cibrian

Rock

Michelle Williams

Kimberly

Brandt Wille

Jared

Bud Cort

Peter

Mink Stole

Nancy

Dante Basco

Dolph

Robert Pine

Mr. Eaton

Rachelle Carson-Begley

Graham's Stepmom

Wesley Mann

Lloyd

Richard Moll

Larry

Julie Delpy

Lipstick Lesbian

Candi Guterres

Extra

Heidi Sulzman

Extra

Jenni Pulos

Cheerleader

Ione Skye

Kelly (uncredited)