Sean Penn

Terry

Ed Harris

Frankie

Gary Oldman

Jackie

Robin Wright

Kathleen

John Turturro

Nick

Burgess Meredith

Finn

R. D. Call

Nicholson

Joe Viterelli

Borelli

John C. Reilly

Stevie

Deirdre O'Connell

Irene

Marco St. John

Cavello

Thomas G. Waites

Frankie's Man #1

Michael Cumpsty

Frankie's Man #3

Daniel O'Shea

Frankie's Man #5

Thomas F. Duffy

Frankie's Man #6

Jamie Tirelli

Alvarez

Sandra Beall

Stevie's Date

Vincent Guastaferro

Borelli's Man #1

Johnny Williams

Borelli's Man #2

John Roselius

Borelli's Man #3

Louis Eppolito

Borelli's Man #4

Mo Gaffney

Maureen

John Ottavino

Raferty's Son

Timothy Klein

Bar Customer #2

Jack Wallace

Matty's Bartender

Frank Girardeau

Bartender #1

Michael P. Moran

Bartender #2

James Russo

DeMarco (uncredited)