Jerry O'Connell

Michael Penorisi

Amanda Peet

Jane Bannister

Sean Patrick Flanery

Rick Hamilton

Tara Reid

Sara Olswang

Ron Livingston

Trent

Emily Procter

Whitney Bryant

Joe Basile

Bartender

Scott Burkholder

Man in Bar

Allison Dunbar

Girl #3

Edmund Genest

Sara's Dad

Adam Lieberman

Burger Joint Cop

Mark Hicks

Bodyguard

Larry Joshua

Detective Richards

Adina Porter

Detective Thompson

Brad Rowe

Shawn Denigan

Wendy Schenker

Doctor

Nick Spano

Jeff the Doorman

Phil Hawn

Club Patron (uncredited)

Cheryl Rusa

Club Patron (uncredited)

Rob Steinberg

Michael's Attorney (uncredited)

Heidi Van Horne

Waitress (uncredited)

Sybil Darrow

Emma Cooper