Tim Allen

Santa / Scott Calvin

Elizabeth Mitchell

Mrs. Claus / Carol

Judge Reinhold

Neil Miller

Wendy Crewson

Laura Miller

Ann-Margret

Sylvia Newman

Eric Lloyd

Charlie

Spencer Breslin

Curtis

Liliana Mumy

Lucy Miller

Alan Arkin

Bud Newman

Martin Short

Jack Frost

Abigail Breslin

Trish

Art LaFleur

Tooth Fairy

Aisha Tyler

Mother Nature

Kevin Pollak

Cupid

Jay Thomas

Easter Bunny

Michael Dorn

Sandman

Peter Boyle

Father Time

Sammi Hanratty

Elf #1

Ridge Canipe

Elf #2

Kate Emerick

Elf #3

Madeline Carroll

Cocoa

Charlie Stewart

Dr. Hismus

Chantel Valdivieso

Worker Elf #1

Zach Mills

Carpenter Elf

John Ross Bowie

Rory

Tim Dougherty

Masonry Elf

Cameron Monaghan

Traffic Cop #1

Ryan Heinke

Traffic Cop #2

Elizabeth Small

Baker Elf

Andrew Vo

Elf #4

Andrea Sweeney-Blanco

Tourist #1 (uncredited)

Tabitha Grayston

Canadian Elf (uncredited)

Christopher Haskell

Parent (uncredited)

Enn Reitel

(voice) (uncredited)

Cameron Scher

Wrapping Elf (uncredited)

Kara R. Stribling

Tourist (uncredited)

Arika Gluck

Elf (uncredited)