Kim Director

Kim Diamond

Jeffrey Donovan

Jeffrey "Jeff" Patterson

Erica Leerhsen

Erica Geerson

Tristine Skyler

Tristen Ryler

Stephen Barker Turner

Stephen Ryan Parker

Lanny Flaherty

Sheriff Cravens

Lauren Hulsey

Eileen Treacle

Raynor Scheine

Rustin Parr

Kennen Sisco

Peggy

Joe Berlinger

Burkittsville Tourist

Pete Burris

MBI Man

Kurt Loder

Kurt Loder

Chuck Scarborough

Chuck Scarborough

Conan O'Brien

Self (archive footage)

Andy Richter

Self (archive footage)

Erik Jensen

Stoner #2

Kevin Murray

Doctor

Keira Naughton

Nurse

Karen Tsen Lee

(voice)

Brian Dragonuk

Angry Citizen at Courthouse

Armen Garo

Doctor

Cathy Haase

First Nurse

Rick Kain

On Camera News Reporter

Chad Ridgely

Photographer

Heather Donahue

Heather Donahue (archive footage) (uncredited)

Joshua Leonard

Joshua Leonard (archive footage) (uncredited)

Michael C. Williams

Michael Williams (archive footage) (uncredited)