Natalie Peri

Desire / Witch

Julie Anne Prescott

Char

Will Collazo Jr.

Ari Carson

Heather Harlow

Bridgette Heckel

Melissa Heflin

Good Mel / Bad Mel / Anne

Erica Dyer

Grace

Tina Krause

Nancy (archive footage)

Clint Beaver

Carl Steel

Kyle Rappaport

Joffrey

Jennie Russo

George Stover

Mr. Carson

Jamie Morgan

Lisa Avery

Rudy Ledbetter

Rudy Ledbetter

Christopher Korek

Entity

Jen Elyse Feldy

Sara Taylor

Josh Kelley

Ashtray Jones

Mark C. Fullhardt

Dark Priest

John Ward

Cult Leader