Talia Ryder

Lillian

Earl Cave

Caleb

Simon Rex

Lawrence

Ayo Edebiri

Molly

Jeremy O. Harris

Matthew

Jacob Elordi

Ian

Rish Shah

Mohammad

Gibby Haynes

Abbot

Jack Irv

Troy

Ella Rubin

Annabel

Tess McMillan

Tessa

Jamie Granato

Tour Guide

Peter Vack

George Washington Boy

Betsey Brown

Betsy Ross Girl

Andy Milonakis

Jeff

Keith Poulson

Keith

MiMi Ryder

Cousin Claire

Jonathan Daniel Brown

Mr. Franks

Adam Friedland

Eric

Nick Pinkerton

Renegade Priest

Patrick M. Walsh

Pattie

Michael Viola

Colonial 2

Lucy Kaminsky

Britni

Sean Price Williams

Uncle Ray

Emmy Harrington

Mrs. Davis (uncredited)