Jared Gilman

Sam Shakusky

Kara Hayward

Suzy Bishop

Bruce Willis

Captain Sharp

Edward Norton

Scout Master Ward

Bill Murray

Mr. Bishop

Frances McDormand

Mrs. Bishop

Tilda Swinton

Social Services

Jason Schwartzman

Cousin Ben

Bob Balaban

The Narrator

Lucas Hedges

Redford

Charlie Kilgore

Lazy Eye

Harvey Keitel

Commander Pierce

Gabriel Rush

Skotak

Seamus Davey-Fitzpatrick

Roosevelt

Tommy Nelson

Nickleby

Larry Pine

Mr. Billingsley

Neal Huff

Jed

Eric Chase Anderson

Secretary McIntire

Jake Ryan

Lionel

Tanner Flood

Murray

Wyatt Ralff

Rudy

Carolyn Pickman

Mrs. Lynn

Ada-Nicole Sanger

Sparrow

Kevin DeCoste

Morse Code Khaki Scout

Coledyn Garrow

Trampoline Khaki Scout

Michael Malvesti

B-B-Q Khaki Scout

Steve Smith

Weather Man (voice)

John Franchi

Play Attendee (uncredited)

Al Conti

Townsman (uncredited)