Mickey Rooney

Mike Halligan

Scott Grimes

Robbie Westin

Barrie Youngfellow

Kate Westin

George Gaynes

Arch Angel

Christina Pickles

Chris

Hamilton Camp

Meek Angel

Elisha Cook Jr.

Mr. Bibbs

Nicholas Hormann

Mr. Jones

Wynn Irwin

Santini

Hector Elias

Ramos

Barbette Tweed

Joanie

Lew Horn

Johnson

Annie Potts

Cindy Mills

Lloyd Nolan

Monsignor Donoghue

Lurene Tuttle

Mrs. Hunt

Garry Goodrow

Cabbie

Beans Morocco

Harried Angel (as Dan Barrows)

Billy Curtis

Elf #2

Jerry Maren

Elf #3

Jan Rooney

Music Teacher (as Jan Chamberlain)

Paddi Edwards

Charity Lady

Michael Laskin

Assistant

Benny Baker

Harry

Gary Imhoff

Freddie the Mailman

Eve Smith

Mrs. Honeywell

Irwin Keyes

Guard

John Welsh

Jogger

Ellen Gerstein

Nurse

Chino 'Fats' Williams

Calvin

Christopher Aber

Mailperson (uncredited)

Mark Rodney

Cop (uncredited)