Val Kilmer

Hall Baltimore

Elle Fanning

V.

Bruce Dern

Sheriff Bobby LaGrange

Ben Chaplin

Edgar Allan Poe

Joanne Whalley

Denise

David Paymer

Sam

Anthony Fusco

Pastor Allan Floyd

Alden Ehrenreich

Flamingo

Don Novello

Melvin

Ryan Simpkins

Caroline

Lucas Rice Jordan

P. J.

Tom Waits

Narrator (voice)