Shirley Temple

Susannah 'Sue' Sheldon

Randolph Scott

Inspector Angus 'Monty' Montague

Margaret Lockwood

Vicky Standing

J. Farrell MacDonald

Pat O'Hannegan

Martin Good Rider

Little Chief

Maurice Moscovitch

Chief Big Eagle

Moroni Olsen

Supt. Andrew Standing

Victor Jory

Wolf Pelt

Lester Matthews

Harlan Chambers

Leyland Hodgson

Randall

Chief John Big Tree

Chief (uncredited)

Herbert Evans

Doctor

Jack Luden

Williams

John Sutton

Corporal Piggott

Herbert Heywood

Hostler

Chief Thunderbird

Indian

James Vincent

Indian