Hilarie Burton

Annie

Gabriel Hogan

John

Tim Matheson

Reginald Buckley

Lola Flanery

Madison

Jayne Eastwood

Mrs. Claus

Derek McGrath

Santa

K. Trevor Wilson

Randy

James Wallis

Tony

Eric Woolfe

Joey

Mike Bell

Hotel Desk Clerk

Darrin Baker

Eliot Shulwater

Leanne Poirier Greenfield

Tanya Leland

Michael Vincent Dagostino

Fred

Lewis Hodgson

Sheriff Jim

Alyssa Piazza

Elf