Geoff Stults

Vince

Mena Suvari

Jane

Jennifer Finnigan

Stephanie

Josh Hopkins

Kenny

Eric Roberts

Mr. Campbell

Kenan Thompson

Mitch

Josh Cooke

Kendrick

Debra Jo Rupp

Tracy

Joey Fatone

Delivery Guy

Tom DeNucci

Reno

Jonathan Silverman

Tom

Kristin Chenoweth

Mrs. Kemp

Dana Ashbrook

Gary

Madeline Merritt

Mrs. Havacamp

Bridget Everett

Stella

Jennifer Jostyn

Regina

Nadia Dajani

Nancy

Jackie Moore

Hot Chick

Tom Papa

Jerk

Maria Kanellis-Bennett

Hot Mess

Patty Ross

Stenographer

Nathan Lesser

Little League Pitcher

Tom Laughlin

Gay Man #1

Nick Principe

Gay Man #2

David Gere

Gay Man #3

Fred Sullivan

Gay Man #5

Gregg Bello

Man with Glasses

Patrick Blank

Gay Clubgoer #1

Chad Verdi Jr.

Gay Clubgoer #3

Pauly Popolizio

Cool Guy in Bar (uncredited)

Amy Rutberg

Regina (Uncredited)

Gary Wolfenden

Club Patron (uncredited)