Whoopi Goldberg

Lucy Cullins

Nigel Hawthorne

Nick

Victor Garber

Taylor

Taylor Negron

Ralph

Frankie Faison

Dwayne

Brian Stokes Mitchell

Cameron

Ali Wentworth

P.A.

Robert Costanzo

Teamster Santa

Bruce Vilanch

Himself

Allyce Beasley

Telemarketer

Juan Carlos Cantu

Doorman

Tinashe

Young Lucy

Ed Gale

Benson

Richard Moll

Brooding Santa

Patti Tippo

Barmaid