Tim Allen

Scott Calvin

Judge Reinhold

Neal

Wendy Crewson

Laura

Eric Lloyd

Charlie

David Krumholtz

Bernard

Larry Brandenburg

Detective Nunzio

Mary Gross

Ms. Daniels

Paige Tamada

Elf-Judy

Peter Boyle

Mr. Whittle

Judith Scott

Susan

Jayne Eastwood

Waitress

Joyce Guy

Principal Compton

Jesse Collins

Ad Executive

David-Paul Grove

Waiter

Steve Vinovich

Dr. Novos

Tabitha Lupien

Ballet Girl

Lachlan Murdoch

Fax Kid

David Sparrow

Bobby's Dad

Scott Wickware

Malone

Michael Caruana

Officer #1

Cody Jones

Child Two

Philip Williams

Sharpshooter

Laura Catalano

Veronica

John Pasquin

Santa #6

Frank Welker

Reindeer Voices (voice)

Kerrigan Mahan

Reindeer Voices (voice)

Nina Keogh

Puppet Judy (voice)