Gina Rodriguez

Mack

Damon Wayans Jr.

Adam

Tom Ellis

Nick Russell

Augustus Prew

Brannagan

Joel Courtney

Ryan 'Little'

Liza Koshy

Ashley

Jerry Kernion

Carl

Ego Nwodim

Claire

Marin Hinkle

Kirk

Gina Jun

VIP Gala Guest

Kais Boukthir

Super Fan

Sterling Jonatán Williams

Tattoo Librarian

Darron Jay Morgan

Holiday Party D.J.

Dan Cordle

Kirk's Husband

George J. Vezina

Sal Greenberg

Sarah Dacey Charles

Mary

Veraalba Santa

Waitress

Tony Foggia

Ticket Taker