Marc Maron

Mel

Jon Bass

Nathaniel

Michaela Watkins

Mary

Jillian Bell

Cynthia

Toby Huss

Hog Jaws

Dan Bakkedahl

Kingpin

Lynn Shelton

Deirdre

Whitmer Thomas

Jake

Benjamin Keepers

Ben

Robert Longstreet

Truther

Michael Patrick O'Brien

Yach

John Winscher

Civil War Conspirator (uncredited)