Alicia Witt

Emma Reynolds

Colin Ferguson

Morgan

Laura Leighton

Andie

Jordan Dean

Daniel

John Palladino

Ian

Jill Larson

Mrs. Jacobs

José Ramón Rosario

Joe

Jack Hallett

Rodney

Stephanie Berry

Mary Bernadette

Mary Elizabeth McDonough

Caroline Reynolds

Ariane Rinehart

Rumi

Blair Lewin

Anne Marie Reynolds

Vin Craig

Cookie Salesman

Kami Cotler

Townsperson (uncredited)

Josiah Harvey

Townsperson / party guest (uncredited)