Britt Robertson

Allie Pennington

Gregg Sulkin

Will Wagner

Joey Pollari

Miles

Devon Graye

Marco

Molly C. Quinn

Jen

Steve Valentine

Mr. Moore

Chris Tavarez

Lance Benwick

Don Lake

Allie's Father

Ingrid Park

Allie's Mother

Anthony Ingruber

Sean

Anton Tennet

Matt

Craig Hall

Coach Barker

Jazmyne Van Gosliga

Susie

Alison Bruce

Coach Miganov

John Leigh

Mr. Atkinson

Andrew Grainger

Campus Cop

Leonard Mathews

Avalon Knights Supporter (uncredited)