Joelle Carter

Amy

Guillermo Díaz

Victor

Jennifer Esposito

Michelle

David Lee Russek

Dom

Vincent Laresca

Nick

Domenick Lombardozzi

Cyrill

Lynn Cohen

Sophia

Phyllis Somerville

Scratchy-voiced Woman

Priscilla Lopez

Mrs. De-Jesus

André Vippolis

Fireboy

Harley Kaplan

Fireboy's Friend

Hazelle Goodman

Lesbian Book Group Leader

Ajay Mehta

Husan

Susan Kellermann

Anthony's Mom / Nava Hannibal (Amy's Mom)

Craig Chester

Caterer

Mickey Cottrell

Father Sebastian

Reathel Bean

Nelson Hannibal

Pat Moya

Mona