Nicolas Cage

Milton

Amber Heard

Piper

William Fichtner

Accountant

Billy Burke

Jonah King

David Morse

Webster

Charlotte Ross

Candy

Christa Campbell

Mona

Tom Atkins

Cap

Katy Mixon

Norma Jean

Jack McGee

Fat Lou

Todd Farmer

Frank

Wanetah Walmsley

American Indian Mother

Edrick Browne

Rookie

Marc Macaulay

Sarge

Pruitt Taylor Vince

Roy

Julius Washington

Uniformed Officer

Jamie Teer

Babysitter

Bryan Massey

Trooper #1

Timothy Walter

Trooper #2

Kent Jude Bernard

Teen #1

Gerry May

TV Male News Reporter #1

Arianne Martin

Milton's Daughter (Older)

Con Schell

Driver

Nick Gomez

Middle

Joe Chrest

Passenger

Oakley Lehman

Cultist with Iron Pipe

Tim J. Smith

Cultist with Hatchet

Jeff 'JJ' Dashnaw

Cowboy with Cattle Prod

Tim Trella

Cultist with Sledge

James Landry Hébert

Man in Leather Jacket

Kenneth Wayne Bradley

Man with Wig

Michael Papajohn

Tattooed Guy

April Littlejohn

Business Woman

Henry Kingi

Thin Old Man

Simona Williams

Lady in Leopard Skin

Elise Fyke

Laughing Cowgirl (uncredited)