Jack Scalia

Joseph 'Joey' Buttafuoco

Alyssa Milano

Amy Fisher

Phyllis Lyons

Mary Jo Buttafuoco

Leo Rossi

Bobby Buttafuoco

J.E. Freeman

Det. Marty Algar

Peter Van Norden

Joey's Attorney

Lawrence Tierney

Joey Buttafucco's Father

Anne DeSalvo

Roseann Fisher

Michael Bowen

Paul Makely

Jack Kehler

Elliot Fisher

Jeff Perry

Amy's Attorney

Mike Girard Sheehan

Vince Donnelly

Nancy Cassaro

Maria

Nick Corello

Frankie

Erick Avari

Surgeon

Paddi Edwards

Pat Connery

Adam LaVorgna

Paulie Buttafuoco

Frank Pesce

Rehab Patient

Bo Dietl

Priest