Hilarie Burton

Katherine

Tyler Hilton

Caleb

Randy Travis

Mr. Greenhall

Markie Post

Lilly

Ed Asner

Papa Noel

Brody Rose

Zach

Ariana Neal

Sienna

Cannon Bosarge

Bryce

Griff Furst

Josh

Samantha Beaulieu

Park Ranger Beth

Odessa Feaster

Local Woman

Dana Gourrier

Janelle

Leticia Jimenez

Kathryn's Assistant

Allen Boudreaux

Store Patron (uncredited)

Tommy Sheppard

Bonfire Goer (uncredited)