Susan Sarandon

Adele August

Natalie Portman

Ann August

Hart Bochner

Josh Spritzer

Eileen Ryan

Lillian

Ray Baker

Ted

John Diehl

Jimmy

Shawn Hatosy

Benny

Bonnie Bedelia

Carol

Faran Tahir

Hisham Badir

Shishir Kurup

Hisham Badir (voice)

Elisabeth Moss

Rachel

John Carroll Lynch

Jack Irwin

Caroline Aaron

Gail Letterfine

Paul Guilfoyle

George Franklin

Thora Birch

Mary

Mary Ellen Trainor

Homeowner

Ashley Johnson

Sarah

Corbin Allred

Peter

Eva Amurri

Girl on TV

Heather DeLoach

Ellen

Stephanie Niznik

Waitress

Heather McComb

Janice Pearlman

Michael Milhoan

Cop

Bob Sattler

Bernie

Jay Harrington

Waiter

Andy Bowles

Mourner

Rick Hurst

Reverend

Rachel Wilson

Sylvia

Nina Barry

Casting Assistant

Lillian Adams

Jack's Mother

Megan Mullally

Woman Buying Car