Lauren LaVera

Sienna Shaw

David Howard Thornton

Art the Clown

Samantha Scaffidi

Victoria Heyes

Elliott Fullam

Jonathan Shaw

Margaret Anne Florence

Jessica

Bryce Johnson

Greg

Alexa Blair Robertson

Mia

Antonella Rose

Gabby

Mason Mecartea

Cole

Krsy Fox

Jennifer

Luciana VanDette

Juliet

Clint Howard

Smokey

Bradley Stryker

Eddie

Daniel Roebuck

Charlie Johnson / Santa Claus

Chris Irvine

Burke

Tom Savini

Bystander

Jason Patric

Michael

Alex Ross

Mark

Kailey Hyman

Brooke

Kellen Raffaelo

Timmy

Jon Abrahams

Dennis

Michael Genet

Maurice Jackson

Luciana Elisa Quiñonez

Young Sienna Shaw

Stephen Cofield Jr.

Officer Evans

Marie Maser

Receptionist

Juliana Lamia

The Virgin Mary

Sienna Hubert-Ross

Stacy Bar Girl #1

Charlotte McKee

Stacy Bar Girl #2

Chip Carriere

Dept Store Santa

Andrew Hollinger

Elf

Lauren Sowa

Mother

Israel Acevedo

Security Guard

Tom White

Angry Parent #4

Annie Lederman

Graven Image Co-Host

Phil Falcone

Tom the Bus Driver

John Sanders

Demon Voice

Jen Ayer Drake

Woman on Bus

Corinne Kelly

Bag Lady

Peter Gray Lewis

Professor Keller (uncredited)

Christian Stavrakis

Mall Witness (uncredited)